Sunray comparative Analysis
Analysis of 12 authentication and security solutions reveals that Sunray occupies a unique position as an integrated security platform, not just an authentication service.
While competitors only provide authentication services ($60 to $216 per year per user), companies still need separate WAF, DDoS protection, bot management, and CDN services (additional infrastructure costs of $4,200 to $40,800 per year).
L'avantage révolutionnaire de Sunray : une pile de sécurité complète (authentification + WAF + DDoS + gestion des bots + CDN + SSL + limitation du débit) pour un total de 108 à 2 268 € par an**, soit une économie de 95 à 98 % par rapport à une infrastructure de sécurité traditionnelle, avec un modèle de déploiement double unique (auto-hébergé + service géré) et une intégration avec Muppy pour un déploiement automatisé. Traduit avec DeepL.com (version gratuite)
#Competitive Landscape Matrix
|
Solution |
Type |
Free Tier |
Starter Plan |
Mid Tier |
Premium |
Enterprise |
|
Sunray |
Self-hosted / Muppy Managed |
✅ €0 self-hosted✅ €9/mo Muppy managed |
€9/mo total (1-20 users) Includes Muppy access |
€9 + €1/user/month |
All advanced features included in paid tiers |
Custom |
|
Cloudflare Access |
Cloud SaaS |
50 users free |
$36/user/year |
- |
$84/user/year |
Custom |
|
Tailscale |
Cloud SaaS |
3 users/100 devices |
$72/user/year |
- |
$216/user/year |
Custom |
|
Auth0 (Okta) |
Cloud SaaS |
7,500 MAU |
$420/year (500 MAU) |
$2,880/year (500 MAU) |
- |
Custom |
|
Okta Workforce |
Cloud SaaS |
Minimal |
$24/user/year (SSO) |
$36/user/year (MFA) |
- |
Custom |
|
Twingate |
Cloud SaaS |
5 users/10 networks |
$60/user/year |
- |
$120/user/year |
Custom |
|
Perimeter 81 |
Cloud SaaS |
❌ |
$96/user/year |
$144/user/year |
$192/user/year |
Custom |
|
NordLayer |
Cloud SaaS |
❌ |
$96/user/year |
$132/user/year |
$168/user/year |
Custom |
|
BeyondTrust PAM |
Enterprise |
❌ |
Custom |
Custom |
Custom |
Custom |
|
CyberArk PAM |
Enterprise |
❌ |
Custom |
Custom |
Custom |
Custom |
|
Keycloak |
Self-hosted |
✅ Free |
✅ Free |
✅ Free |
✅ Free |
Red Hat support |
|
Authentik |
Self-hosted |
✅ Free |
✅ Free |
✅ Free |
✅ Free |
Consulting available |
|
Authelia |
Self-hosted |
✅ Free |
✅ Free |
✅ Free |
✅ Free |
Community only |
|
Solution |
No Code Mod |
Cross-Platform |
Nothing to Install |
Partial Site Protection |
Scope Level |
Data Sovereignty |
WAF Protection |
DDoS Protection |
Bot Management |
Rate Limiting |
Edge Security |
Complete Stack |
|
Sunray |
✅ Reverse proxy |
✅ Web/Mobile/API |
✅ Browser only |
✅ URL-based rules |
HTTP level |
✅ Full control |
✅ Cloudflare WAF |
✅ Free tier included |
✅ Automatic |
✅ Built-in |
✅ Global edge |
✅ Auth+WAF+DDoS+CDN |
|
Cloudflare Access |
✅ Reverse proxy |
✅ Web/Mobile/API |
✅ Browser only |
✅ URL-based rules |
HTTP level |
❌ Cloudflare servers |
✅ Cloudflare WAF |
✅ Included |
✅ Included |
✅ Included |
✅ Global edge |
✅ Auth+WAF+DDoS+CDN |
|
Tailscale |
❌ Requires config |
✅ All platforms |
❌ Client install |
❌ Network level |
L3/L4 network |
⚠️ Control plane only |
❌ Need separate WAF |
❌ Need separate DDoS |
❌ No bot protection |
❌ Basic limits only |
❌ Network level |
❌ VPN only |
|
Auth0 (Okta) |
❌ Code integration |
✅ Web/Mobile/API |
✅ Browser only |
✅ Application level |
HTTP level |
❌ Okta servers |
❌ Need separate WAF |
❌ Need separate DDoS |
❌ No bot protection |
⚠️ Basic API limits |
❌ Origin only |
❌ Auth only |
|
Okta Workforce |
❌ Code integration |
✅ Web/Mobile/API |
✅ Browser only |
✅ Application level |
HTTP level |
❌ Okta servers |
❌ Need separate WAF |
❌ Need separate DDoS |
❌ No bot protection |
⚠️ Basic API limits |
❌ Origin only |
❌ Auth only |
|
Twingate |
❌ Requires config |
✅ All platforms |
❌ Client install |
✅ Resource level |
L3/L4 network |
⚠️ Control plane only |
❌ Need separate WAF |
❌ Need separate DDoS |
❌ No bot protection |
⚠️ Basic limits |
❌ Network level |
❌ Network access only |
|
Perimeter 81 |
❌ Requires config |
✅ All platforms |
❌ Client install |
✅ Gateway rules |
L3/L4 network |
❌ Cloud gateways |
⚠️ Basic WAF ($extra) |
⚠️ Basic DDoS ($extra) |
❌ Limited |
✅ Gateway limits |
⚠️ Gateway level |
⚠️ SASE platform |
|
NordLayer |
❌ Requires config |
✅ All platforms |
❌ Client install |
✅ Gateway rules |
L3/L4 network |
❌ Cloud gateways |
❌ Need separate WAF |
⚠️ Basic DDoS |
❌ Limited |
⚠️ Basic limits |
❌ VPN level |
❌ VPN focus |
|
BeyondTrust PAM |
❌ Agent required |
✅ All platforms |
❌ Agent install |
✅ System level |
System level |
⚠️ Hybrid options |
❌ Need separate WAF |
❌ Need separate DDoS |
❌ No web protection |
⚠️ Session limits |
❌ System level |
❌ PAM only |
|
CyberArk PAM |
❌ Agent required |
✅ All platforms |
❌ Agent install |
✅ System level |
System level |
⚠️ Hybrid options |
❌ Need separate WAF |
❌ Need separate DDoS |
❌ No web protection |
⚠️ Session limits |
❌ System level |
❌ PAM only |
|
Keycloak |
❌ Code integration |
✅ Web/Mobile/API |
✅ Browser only |
✅ Application level |
HTTP level |
✅ Full control |
❌ Need separate WAF |
❌ Need separate DDoS |
❌ No bot protection |
⚠️ Manual config |
❌ Origin only |
❌ Auth only |
|
Authentik |
✅ Reverse proxy |
✅ Web/Mobile/API |
✅ Browser only |
✅ URL-based rules |
HTTP level |
✅ Full control |
❌ Need separate WAF |
❌ Need separate DDoS |
❌ No bot protection |
⚠️ Manual config |
❌ Origin only |
❌ Auth only |
|
Authelia |
✅ Forward auth |
✅ Web/Mobile/API |
✅ Browser only |
✅ URL-based rules |
HTTP level |
✅ Full control |
❌ Need separate WAF |
❌ Need separate DDoS |
❌ No bot protection |
⚠️ Manual config |
❌ Origin only |
❌ Auth only |
#🛡️ Integrated Security Stack Analysis
#The Hidden Infrastructure Costs
Most authentication solutions only provide the authentication layer. Companies still need separate services to ensure complete security for web applications:
Traditional safety requirements:
Authentication Service: $60-200/user/year WAF Protection: $20-200/month ($240-2,400/year) DDoS Protection: $200-2,000/month ($2,400-24,000/year) Bot Management: $50-500/month ($600-6,000/year) CDN/Performance: $50-500/month ($600-6,000/year) Rate Limiting: $20-100/month ($240-1,200/year) SSL Management: $10-100/month ($120-1,200/year) TOTAL INFRASTRUCTURE: $4,200-40,800/year + per-user costs
Integrated Sunray stack:
Complete Security Platform: €108-2,268/year total Includes: Auth + WAF + DDoS + Bot Management + CDN + Rate Limiting + SSL COST SAVINGS: 95-98% vs traditional stack
#Competitive Advantage Matrix
Solution | Complete Stack | Additional Services Needed | True Annual Cost Examples |
Sunray | ✅ Everything included | None | €108 (20 users) • €948 (100 users) |
Cloudflare Access | ✅ Everything included | None | $720-1,680 (20 users) • $3,600-8,400 (100 users) |
Auth0/Okta | ❌ Auth only | WAF+DDoS+CDN+Bot ($4,200+/year) | $5,400+ (20 users) • $12,600+ (100 users) |
Authentik/Authelia | ❌ Auth only | WAF+DDoS+CDN+Bot ($4,200+/year) | $4,200+ (any size) |
Tailscale/Twingate | ❌ Network access only | WAF+DDoS+CDN+Bot ($4,200+/year) | $5,640+ (20 users) • $10,200+ (100 users) |
Enterprise PAM | ❌ System access only | Full web security stack ($8,000+/year) | $8,000+ (any size) |
#Why This Matters
For web applications, you need a comprehensive security stack. Sunray is the only solution (besides Cloudflare Access) that offers:
- ✅ Authentication (passwordless passkeys)
- ✅ WAF Protection (OWASP Top 10, SQL injection, XSS)
- ✅ DDoS Mitigation (up to the most significant attacks on a global scale)
- ✅ Bot Management (challenge/automatic block)
- ✅ Rate Limiting (per-IP and per-user)
- ✅ Edge Security (sub-100ms globally)
- ✅ SSL/TLS (certificats automatiques)
- ✅ CDN Performance (200+ global PoPs)
All this for a total of €9 to €189 per month, compared to $4,000 to $40,000 or more per year for an equivalent traditional setup.
💡 Sunray's competitive advantages
🛡 Full advantage of the security stack
- Integrated platform - Authentication + WAF + DDoS + Bot management + CDN in a single solution
- Cloudflare backbone - Leverages the world's largest edge network with over 200 global points of presence
- Zero additional infrastructure - No separate WAF, DDoS protection, or CDN services are required.
- Enterprise-grade security included in all tiers (even free and self-hosted ones)
- Automatic threat mitigation - DDoS attacks, bot attacks, and web vulnerabilities blocked at the edge
- Global performance - Authentication response time under 100 ms worldwide
#💰 Revolutionary Price Disruption
- 95-98% cost savings vs complete security stack alternatives
- €108-2,268/year total vs $4,200-40,800/year traditional infrastructure
- No per-user scaling for infrastructure costs (fixed monthly rates)
- No surprise bills - WAF, DDoS protection, and CDN included
- Predictable pricing with transparent tiered structure
⚡ Technical Differentiation
- Zero code modification - Protects any existing web app via reverse proxy
- Universal compatibility - Works on desktop, mobile, and M2M (APIs/webhooks)
- Nothing to install - Browser-only solution, no client software required
- Granular protection - Protect specific URL paths (e.g., /admin) while leaving public areas open
- Edge-first architecture - Security and performance at CDN edge, not origin servers
- WebAuthn passkeys - Modern, phishing-resistant authentication
- Deployment flexibility - Self-hosted OR managed service on your infrastructure
- Data sovereignty - Your data never leaves your infrastructure (both deployment options)
- Enterprise-ready platform - Built on proven Odoo framework for reliability and scalability
- Open source foundation - Transparency and customizability
#Market Gap
- Between expensive cloud SaaS and complex self-hosted OSS
- Legacy application modernization - Add modern auth to existing web apps without code changes
- Mixed environment protection - Public sites with protected admin areas
- API-first security - Webhook and API authentication without network complexity
- Managed service option - Self-hosted benefits without operational burden
- SME to Enterprise - Scales from startups to large organizations